Crisp edges, gooey center, melty dark chocolate, and flaky sea salt-the cookie that started it all.
A deeply rich dark chocolate cookie infused with fragrant Earl Grey tea, balancing bold cocoa notes with a delicate floral finish.
Rich, salty-sweet, and beautifully indulgent, with creamy peanut butter cups and decadent chocolate in every bite.
Twelve handmade brown butter cookies — the full experience.
Choose your style below:
Baker's Choice — We do the work. Your box comes with 4 cookies of each of this week's three flavors, automatically curated. No flavor selection needed.
Assorted — Build your own box. In the order notes at checkout, tell us your flavor breakdown and quantities (e.g. "2 Chocolate Chunk, 5 London Fog, 5 Shahi"). Make sure your total adds up to 12 cookies. We'll pack it exactly as you like.
Available flavors: Original (Chocolate Chunk), Midnight (Dark Chocolate Earl Grey), Cup (Peanut Butter Chocolate).
Small-batch, thoughtfully made, and limited in quantity. Order yours before they're gone.
Allergen Notice: Our cookies are made in a kitchen where wheat, dairy, eggs, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts are present. We cannot guarantee products are free from cross-contact.
Six handmade brown butter cookies packed in a signature Butter'd Drop box.
Choose your style below:
Baker's Choice — We do the work. Your box comes with 2 cookies of each of this week's three flavors, automatically curated. No flavor selection needed.
Assorted — Build your own box. In the order notes at checkout, tell us your flavor breakdown (e.g. "3 Chocolate Chunk, 3 London").
Make sure your total adds up to 6 cookies. We'll pack it exactly as you like.
Premium flavors, limited quantities, made with care.
Allergen Notice: Our cookies are made in a kitchen where wheat, dairy, eggs, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts are present. We cannot guarantee products are free from cross-contact.
Three handmade brown butter cookies — your pick, your way. Choose one flavor from this week's drop and get 3 cookies of that flavor. Small-batch, premium, and made with love. Limited quantities — order before they're gone.
Allergen Notice: Our cookies are made in a kitchen where wheat, dairy, eggs, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts are present. We cannot guarantee products are free from cross-contact.
No results match your search. Try removing a few filters.